Methodology & Independence

Solomon neither accepts revenue from nor gives money to anyone it measures.
It also takes no revenue from data vendors serving hospitals.

The First Independent Hospital Affordability BenchmarkBuilt Entirely from Hospitals' Own Published Price Files

The public records required under the federal transparency rule.

260% of Medicare
The Solomon Standard™ threshold, the benchmark Indiana wrote into law in House Enrolled Act 1004 for hospital contracts with employers.
Public recordsEvery input is a file the hospital itself published and attested.
Same serviceEach price is read against what Medicare pays for it.
Twelve statesApplied across the Solomon Report series so far.
No allegationA price above the line is a measurement, not a legal finding.

What It Measures

The Solomon Standard™ measures hospital prices against Medicare. Under 45 CFR Part 180, every hospital is required to publish a machine-readable file of its list prices, cash prices, and negotiated rates by payer. The Solomon Standard benchmarks each of these against what Medicare pays for the same service.

The measurement is applied state by state, hospital by hospital, service by service. A price above the Solomon Standard is not illegal. It is a measure of how far that price has moved from the nearest public reference point in American healthcare.

The Threshold

Indiana's House Enrolled Act 1004 requires the state's largest nonprofit hospital systems to offer employer contracts at or below 260% of Medicare. The Solomon Standard adopts this line as its national benchmark, not because it is the ideal price, but because a legislature defined it, and it gives every measurement a fixed, public line to be read against.

Several states have written Medicare-based limits into law: Oregon at 200% for its state employee plans, Delaware at 250% as a temporary cap during its hospital budget reforms, and Indiana at 260% for hospital contracts with employers. The Solomon Standard uses the highest of these. A price above 260% of Medicare is above each of them, so no finding depends on choosing a strict threshold. In addition, because Indiana's line governs employer contracts, it measures the market the Solomon Standard is built to serve.

The Market Evidence

A benchmark is only useful if it is achievable. Findings from three states, and from different payers in each, confirm that hospital pricing near Medicare is not theoretical. No single plan defines it.

Evidence× MedicareScope
Florida inpatient floor, lowest negotiated rate per stay, range1.06× to 1.73×51 hospitals
New York inpatient floor, lowest negotiated rate per DRG, median1.08×15 hospitals
SCAN Health Plan, California inpatient contracts, median1.12×3 hospitals

In Florida, at 51 hospitals with a real floor, the lowest negotiated rate per stay sits between 1.06 and 1.73 times Medicare, a band that includes SCAN's California median of 1.12. One plan, Clear Spring Health, sets the floor at 26 of the 75 hospitals with readable payer data.

In New York, at 12 of 15 hospitals with usable inpatient data, the lowest negotiated rate is set by a Medicare Advantage plan: Aetna, Anthem, Healthfirst, Fidelis, Independent Health, or Excellus, depending on the hospital. The median floor across all 15 hospitals is 1.08 times Medicare. The affordable inpatient rate exists at every one of these hospitals, in writing. It is the rate the hospital has agreed to with a Medicare Advantage plan.

SCAN Health Plan's California inpatient contracts pay a median of 1.12 times Medicare and never cross the 260% line. SCAN's California contracts, the series' original control, are one of the Solomon Standard's founding market inputs, alongside the floors above.

Three states. Different payers. The same finding: hospitals already accept rates near Medicare from someone. Every one of these floors sits well below the Solomon Standard's 260% line.

The Solomon Standard does not ask every purchaser to pay what the most disciplined payer pays. It marks the point where a price has moved more than twice as far from Medicare as rates hospitals already accept.

The Data Source

Every measurement in the Solomon Standard is built from hospital machine-readable files published under the federal Hospital Price Transparency rule (45 CFR Part 180). These files are published by the hospitals themselves, attested as accurate and complete, and available to anyone. No one can withdraw the data, and no one has to agree to share it.

For inpatient stays, Medicare's payment is calculated per hospital using each facility's own wage-adjusted operating base rate, derived from its CMS Provider of Services file and the applicable wage index. A stay at a rural hospital in North Carolina is compared to what Medicare pays that specific hospital, not a national average. Outpatient services are compared with the 2026 Medicare rate for the same code: Medicare's national Physician Fee Schedule rate, or its hospital outpatient (OPPS) payment where that is lower. Services Medicare prices only through its hospital outpatient system are compared with their OPPS payment. Clinical laboratory tests are reported as a separate measure.

The Solomon Standard does not use payer transparency files (Transparency in Coverage), claims data, survey data, or any proprietary data source. Every input is a public record.

In August 2026, Solomon Copilot submitted a public comment to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) addressing the accuracy of hospital pricing data and advocating for greater price transparency through the disclosure of prices as a percentage of Medicare rates (CMS-2026-2344-1337).

What the Solomon Standard Does and Does Not Say

Outside specific state caps, such as Delaware's, a price above 260% of Medicare is not, by itself, a violation of any law. The Solomon Standard does not allege fraud, overcharging, or noncompliance. It measures the distance between what a hospital publishes and what Medicare, the largest single payer in the country, pays for the same service.

The Solomon Standard does not measure quality of care, patient outcomes, or hospital operating costs. A hospital that prices above the line may deliver excellent care. A hospital that prices below it may not. Price and quality are separate questions. The Solomon Standard addresses one of them.

Coverage

As of November 2026, the Solomon Standard has been applied across twelve states. The Solomon Report series intends to measure all fifty.

All published reports are available at solomoncopilot.com/reports.html.

Version History

Version 1.1, October 22, 2026. Adds outpatient services that Medicare prices only through its hospital outpatient system. Reports clinical laboratory tests as a separate measure. Measures services on Medicare's Physician Fee Schedule against its national rate; version 1 used an average of Medicare's 109 local rates. Across the ten states measured, the share of hospital list prices above the Solomon Standard is 82.6% under version 1.1, compared with 84.2% under version 1. Published reports remain as measured under version 1.

Version 1, October 8, 2026. Initial release.

An affordable price already exists in the hospitals' own files. It is reserved for the insurer that negotiated it.